Tsarin Gudanar da Kudaden shiga na Lottery

Tsarin caca an tsara su ne a kusa da wani tsari mai sauƙi: sayen tikiti yana samar da tarin kuɗi wanda dole ne a raba shi tsakanin wurare daban-daban. Fahimtar wannan rarraba yana da mahimmanci don fahimtar yadda gwamnatoci ke amfana daga sayar da tikiti. Yawanci, ana raba kudaden shiga daga sayar da tikiti zuwa manyan rukuni uku: biyan kuɗi, kuɗin aiki, da kudaden shiga na gwamnati. Kyautar kyauta sau da yawa suna cinye mafi girman rabo, yawanci tsakanin 50% zuwa 60% na jimlar tallace-tallace, dangane da ikon da takamaiman wasa. Sashe na biyu ya tafi zuwa farashin gudanarwa, gami da kwamitocin kiri, tallan, tsaro, da fasaha.

Kashi da yawa da ke gudana cikin akwatunan gwamnati ya bambanta da ƙasa har ma da jihohi. Misali, United Kingdom National Lottery (FLT: 1) yana ba da kashi 28% na kudaden shiga na tikiti ga "Mafi kyawun dalilai" (art, al'adun gargajiya, wasanni, da ayyukan al'umma), yayin da caca ta jihar a Amurka yawanci ke ba da gudummawa 25%35% ga kudaden da aka ƙayyade, galibi ilimi. A Kanada, caca ta lardin tana ba da wani ɓangare ga kudaden shiga na gaba ɗaya kuma tana ba da kuɗi ga shirye-shiryen kiwon lafiya da zamantakewa. Ana yin cikakken rarrabuwa, wanda ke sa shi ya zama siyasa da kuma yanke shawara ta tattalin arziki. Wasu hukuma, kamar Faransa's: 2FDJFLT: 3 (Française des Jeux), a ƙarƙashin wani samfurin daban inda jihar ke da hannun jari da yawa da ribar da ke gudana cikin tsarin kasafin kuɗi. Wannan bambancin ba ya nuna daidaituwa kai tsaye; babu tsarin kasafin kuɗi na gida da ke nuna bambancin tarihi; babu daidaitattun hanyoyin da ke nuna daidaito na musamman; babu daidaitattun tsarin kasafin

A cikin lokuta masu mahimmanci, kashi na rarraba ba su da tsayayye. Lotteries da yawa suna daidaita yawan biyan kuɗi lokaci-lokaci don kiyaye sha'awar ɗan wasa, yayin da farashin aiki na iya ƙaruwa saboda hauhawar farashi ko sabbin buƙatun tsaro. Misali, bayan halatta 2018 na caca ta wasanni a Amurka, wasu lotteries sun fuskanci ƙaruwar gasa kuma sun amsa ta hanyar haɓaka adadin kyaututtuka ko gabatar da sabbin tsarin wasa. Wannan sake daidaitawa na yau da kullun yana nufin hannun jarin gwamnati na iya raguwa ko girma a tsawon lokaci, amma tushen tushen ya kasance tushen tushen samun kuɗi mai aminci a yawancin kasuwannin da suka manyanta.

Yadda Gwamnatoci Suke Amfani da Riba Daga Fitar Cin Kuɗi

Yawancin gwamnatoci suna sanya waɗannan kudaden don takamaiman dukiyar jama'a, wanda ke taimakawa wajen gina goyon bayan jama'a ga tsarin caca. Mafi yawan masu amfani da su shine ilimi, kayayyakin more rayuwa, da kuma ayyukan zamantakewa. Ƙididdigar kuma tana haifar da kusurwar talla mai ƙarfi: lokacin da 'yan wasa suka san kuɗin su zai tallafa wa makarantu ko asibitoci, suna iya jin daɗin gudummawar jama'a.

Kudaden da ake bayarwa don ilimi

Ilimi shine mafi girma mai karɓar kudaden shiga daga caca a yawancin jihohin Amurka. Loto na California, wanda aka kafa a 1984, ya ba da gudummawar sama da dala biliyan 39 ga makarantu da kwalejoji na gwamnati. Ana rarraba kudade ga makarantu K12, kwalejojin al'umma, da jami'o'in jihar, galibi suna ba da ƙarin albarkatu don littattafai na makaranta, fasaha, da haɓaka wurare. Hakanan, New York Lottery FLT:3 ya ba da gudummawar sama da dala biliyan 70 ga ilimi tun lokacin da aka kafa shi. New York tana amfani da kuɗin caca don ƙarin taimakon jihar ga makarantu, tare da wani ɓangare da aka ware musamman don tallafawa yankuna masu ƙarancin kuɗi. Sauran jihohi, kamar Georgia, Tennessee suna amfani da kudaden shiga daga lotto don tsarin karatun ILTFL: 5, wanda ke ba da taimako ga mazauna Florida.

Duk da waɗannan gudummawar, kudaden caca ba sa sauya kasafin kuɗi na ilimi. Masu sukar sun lura cewa kudaden shiga na caca galibi suna ba da damar majalisa su rage sauran kuɗin ilimi, a zahiri maye gurbin maimakon ƙarin. Nazarin 2021 na Hukumar Tattalin Arziki ta Kasa ta gano cewa don kowane dala na kudaden shiga na caca da aka keɓe don ilimi, kuɗin jihar don ilimi ya ragu da kusan cent 75. Duk da haka, rarraba ya haifar da labari mai ƙarfi wanda ke haɗa sayen tikiti kai tsaye zuwa ɗakunan karatu, yana sa caca ta zama mafi ɗanɗano a siyasa.

Tsarin Tattalin Arziki da Ayyukan Jama'a

Wasu gwamnatoci suna tura ribar caca zuwa ayyukan jari. Lottery na ƙasa na Burtaniya, ta hanyar asusunsa na "Good Causes", ya ba da kuɗi ga manyan ayyuka kamar aikin Eden a Cornwall, fadada Tate Modern, da London 2012 Olympic Park. A Amurka, jihohi kamar Pennsylvania da Texas sun yi amfani da kudaden shiga na lottery don kula da tituna, gyaran gada, da haɓaka tsarin ruwa. Gwamnatocin gida ma suna amfana: a cikin gari da yawa, kudaden lottery suna taimakawa gina wuraren shakatawa, ɗakunan karatu, da cibiyoyin al'umma. Misali, Lottery na Oregon ya ba da gudummawar miliyoyin daloli ga ayyukan ci gaban tattalin arziki, gami da fadada Filin jirgin saman Portland.

Ana amfani da kuɗin da ake kashewa don yin amfani da kayan aikin caca don hana karuwar haraji. Duk da haka, adadin yana da ƙarancin gaske idan aka kwatanta da yawan bukatun kayayyakin more rayuwa. Misali, kudaden caca sun kai ƙasa da 1% na yawan kuɗin da ake kashewa a kan titin Amurka. Duk da haka, a cikin mawuyacin lokacin kuɗi, ko da ƙananan gudummawa na iya taimakawa wajen hana jinkirin aikin ko ba da damar hanzarta haɓaka manyan abubuwa. Wasu masu sukar suna jayayya cewa amfani da kudaden shiga na caca don kayan aikin yana haifar da dogaro mai haɗari ga tsarin samun kuɗi mai saurin canzawa, amma yawancin jihohi suna da kariya don tabbatar da cewa mahimman ayyukan ba su dogara gaba ɗaya akan kudaden shiga caca ba.

Shirye-shiryen Kula da Al'adu da Lafiya

Yawancin hukumomi suna rarraba kudaden shiga daga caca ga kula da lafiya da kuma hanyoyin tsaro na zamantakewa. Lotto na jihar na Ostiraliya, alal misali, suna tallafawa kayan aikin asibiti, sabis na kiwon lafiya na hankali, da shirye-shiryen kula da shan ƙwayoyi. A Burtaniya, wani ɓangare na kudaden shiga na Lotto na ƙasa yana tallafawa binciken kiwon lafiya ta hanyar ƙungiyoyi kamar FLT:2 Wellcome Trust. Wasu jihohin Amurka, kamar Ohio, suna kai tsaye ribar lotto zuwa rigakafi da magani, suna yarda da abin dariya cewa tushen kuɗin guda ɗaya na iya ƙara matsalolin caca.

Shirye-shiryen tsofaffi, tsoffin sojoji, da iyalai masu ƙarancin kuɗi ma masu karɓar riba ne. Misali, Lottery na Illinois yana ba da gudummawa ga asusu wanda ke ba da ragi na harajin ƙasa ga tsofaffi da nakasassu. Duk da yake waɗannan abubuwan da aka rarraba suna da ƙanƙanci dangane da yawan kuɗin zamantakewar gaba ɗaya, suna nuna yadda za a iya tallata caca azaman kayan aikin samun kuɗi na zamantakewa. Duk da haka, yawanci adadin yana da ƙanƙanci don samun tasirin tsarin da ya dace, wanda ke haifar da zargi cewa ana amfani da caca don yin rubutun ra'ayin kan gibin kasafin kuɗi maimakon inganta jin daɗin zamantakewa da gaske.

Tasirin Ƙara Ƙara a Tattalin Arziki

Bayan samun kudaden shiga kai tsaye, ayyukan caca suna haifar da tasirin tattalin arziki na biyu. Wadannan tasirin raɗaɗi galibi masu bayar da shawarar suna ambata su azaman ƙarin dalili don caca ta jihar. Ana iya auna tasirin ninkawa a cikin ƙirƙirar ayyuka, ƙaruwar kashe kuɗin sayar da kayayyaki, har ma da yawon buɗe ido.

Samar da Ayyuka da Ƙaruwar Kasuwancin Sadarwa

Lotteries na buƙatar ma'aikata don buga tikiti, rarrabawa, tallace-tallace, tallace-tallace, tsaro, da gudanarwa. A cikin manyan jihohi, aikin caca na iya zama ɗaruruwa ko dubbai. Misali, Loterin New York kai tsaye yana ɗaukar mutane 300, amma mafi girman yanayin halittu ciki har da masu siyar da tikiti suna tallafawa dubban ayyuka. Shagunan cin abinci, tashoshin mai, da shagunan sayar da kayayyaki suna amfana daga ƙaruwar zirga-zirgar ƙafa daga 'yan wasan caca. Nazarin ya nuna cewa sayar da caca yana haɓaka yawan kuɗin siyarwa a waɗannan wuraren da kashi 5% 15%.

Kwamishinan kiri wani tashar samun fa'ida ce ta tattalin arziki. A yawancin hukuma, yan kasuwa suna samun 5% -7% na siyarwar tikiti. Wannan ƙarfafawa tana ƙarfafa ƙananan kamfanoni su shiga. Ga shagunan masu zaman kansu da yawa, sayar da caca yana wakiltar karuwar kudaden shiga mai karko ko da a lokacin koma bayan tattalin arziki. A lokacin annobar COVID-19, alal misali, sayar da caca ya tabbatar da kasancewa mai karko fiye da sauran rukunonin kiri, yana samar da buffer ga shagunan cikin gida. Duk da haka, wasu masu sukar suna jayayya cewa lokaci da ƙoƙari da aka kashe akan gudanar da caca na iya jan hankalin daga sauran ayyukan kiri, kuma cewa farashin zamantakewar caca na iya cutar da al'ummomin da ke amfana daga kwamitocin.

Yawon Bude Ido da kuma Sha'awar Abubuwan da Suka faru

Babban jackpot na iya jawo masu sayen tikiti a fadin iyakoki, musamman a yankuna inda caca ta iyakance. Misali, lokacin da US Powerball ko Mega Millions jackpots suka tashi, mazauna jihohin da ba su da caca (kamar Alabama, Alaska, da Hawaii) suna tafiya zuwa jihohin makwabta don siyan tikiti. Hakazalika, "Lotto" na National Lottery na Burtaniya yana haifar da haɓaka na wucin gadi a cikin tallace-tallace a cikin shagunan cin abinci a ranakun zanawa. Wasu biranen ma sun yi amfani da kudaden caca don tallafawa kayan aikin yawon buɗe ido, kamar cibiyoyin taro ko wuraren wasanni, suna ƙara ninka fa'idodin tattalin arziki.

Bugu da ƙari, ayyukan fasaha da al'adu da aka ba da kuɗin caca kamar nune-nunen a Tate Modern ko wasan kwaikwayo a Royal Opera House suna jan hankalin baƙi na duniya waɗanda ke kashe kuɗi a otal-otal, gidajen abinci, da sufuri. Wannan yana haifar da tarin fa'idodi na tattalin arziki waɗanda suka wuce siyar da tikiti na asali.

Yanayin da Ya Saci Baya da Kudaden Al'umma

Duk da fa'idodin tattalin arziki, caca suna fuskantar mummunan zargi saboda tasirin su na koma baya. Haraji mai koma baya shine wanda ya fi yawa a kan mutane masu samun kuɗi mafi ƙanƙanci a matsayin kashi na kuɗin shiga. Kudin caca yana da tsada sosai a tsakanin gidajen da ke da ƙananan kuɗi. A cewar binciken da Hukumar Kula da Tattalin Arziki ta Kasa ta gudanar, 'yan wasan caca a cikin ƙananan kuɗin shiga na ƙasa suna kashe babban rabo daga ribar su akan tikiti fiye da waɗanda ke cikin babban kwantel. Wannan tsarin ya sa caca ta zama nau'in haraji na son rai na koma baya, wanda ke haifar da damuwa ta ɗabi'a.

Ciwon caca wani mummunan halin zamantakewa ne. Ƙungiyar likitancin Amurka ta lissafa matsalar caca a matsayin yanayin da aka sani, kuma caca ta jihohi ita ce babbar hanyar shiga ga yawancin masu caca masu matsala. Nazarin ya kiyasta cewa 1%2% na 'yan wasan caca suna haɓaka mahimman matsalolin caca. Kudin da ya haifar da hakan magani, asarar yawan aiki, rushewar iyali, da haɓaka aikata laifi na iya daidaita wasu fa'idodin gwamnati. Rahoton 2019 na Majalisar Kasa kan Matsalar Caca FLT:1 ya kiyasta cewa farashin zamantakewar caca a Amurka ya kasance daga dala biliyan 6 zuwa dala biliyan 30 a kowace shekara, dangane da hanyar lissafin kuɗi. A sakamakon haka, yawancin caca yanzu suna tallafawa caca mai alhaki, amma masu sukar suna jayayya cewa waɗannan matakan basu isa ba. Jihohi kaɗan ne kawai, kamar Oregon da Washington, sun ba da izinin cewa kashi na musamman na ayyukan caca su zama na musamman ga ayyukan cin zarafin caca.

Tambayoyin gaskiya kuma suna shafar tattalin arzikin caca. Gwamnatoci galibi ba su da cikakken bayani game da yadda ake kashe kuɗin caca. Misali, an zargi wasu jihohi da amfani da kuɗin caca don rufe gibin kasafin kuɗi maimakon ƙarin shirye-shiryen da ake so. Binciken 2017 na kamfanin dillancin labaran da aka yi ya gano cewa jihohi da yawa, gami da California da Texas, sun rage kasafin kuɗaɗen iliminsu da ainihin adadin kuɗin caca, wanda ke kawar da ma'anar "ƙarin" kudaden shiga. Wannan rashin haɗin tsakanin alkawuran talla da ainihin rarrabawar zai iya lalata amincin jama'a. Don magance wannan, wasu hukumomi yanzu suna buƙatar rahotanni na shekara-shekara na bin diddigar kuɗin caca zuwa ga shirye-shiryen takamaiman, amma tilasta da gaskiya ba su da daidaito.

Nazarin Kasuwanci na Duniya

Binciken yadda kasashe daban-daban ke gudanar da caca ya nuna hanyoyi da dama na daidaita samar da kudaden shiga da kuma alhakin zamantakewa. Kowane samfurin yana da ƙarfinsa da kuma raunana, yana ba da darussa ga masu yanke shawara a duniya.

Ƙasar Ingila

Lottery na kasa na Burtaniya, wanda Kamelot Group (yanzu Allwyn Entertainment) ke sarrafawa, yana daya daga cikin tsarin da ya fi bayyane. An sanya wani adadin tallace-tallace ga "Good Causes": zane-zane, al'adun gargajiya, wasanni, da ayyukan al'umma. Tun 1994, ya tara sama da £ 47 biliyan don waɗannan dalilai, tare da ayyukan da aka bayar ta hanyar masu rarraba masu zaman kansu kamar Heritage Lottery Fund da Sport England. National Lottery kuma yana tallafawa Asusun Tallafin Lottery na Kasa, wanda ke tallata tasirin zamantakewar irin wannan lotirin. Wannan samfurin yana da babban amincewar jama'a saboda masu amfani suna bayyane da bambancin. Misali, sabon lambun [[FLT: 2]] na Gidan Tarihi na Tarihi na Tarihi na {FLT: 3]] an tallafawa shi ne ta hanyar ba da kyautar £ 12.5 miliyan daga Asusun Lottery Heritage. Duk da haka tsarin kula da lafiyar Burtaniya yana da ƙarfi sosai, tare da kula da masu sukar kai tsaye da rahoto na jama'a.

Ostiraliya

Lotto na jihar Australia (misali, Tatts Group a Victoria, Golden Casket a Queensland) ya dawo da ribar ga gwamnatocin jihohi. Wadannan kudade galibi suna tallafawa ayyukan kiwon lafiya, kamar haɓaka asibitoci da bincike na likita. Misali, Gwamnatin Queensland ta yi amfani da ribar lotto don tallafawa fadada asibitin Redcliffe na dala miliyan 5. Lotocin New South Wales sun kuma ba da gudummawa ga asusun agaji na jihar, suna ba da kuɗi don dawo da bala'in daji a 20192020.

Singapore

Singapore Toto, wanda Singapore Pools ke sarrafawa, yana wakiltar wani lamari na musamman: mallakar ƙasa tare da tsauraran dokoki. Kudaden shiga suna zuwa ga Tote Board, wanda ke tura kuɗi zuwa ci gaban al'umma, wasanni, da kuma ayyukan zamantakewa. Lotto na Singapore yana cikin wani ɓangare na wani babban dabarun da ya haɗa da haraji mai yawa akan gidajen caca da layin taimakon caca na ƙasa. Gwamnati ta jaddada cewa kudaden shiga na caca kai tsaye suna tallafawa al'umma, rage lalata da ke tattare da kudaden shiga na caca. Misali, Community Chest (FLT: 0), wanda ke tallafawa hukumomin sabis na zamantakewa sama da 100, yana karɓar manyan tallafi daga Tote Board. Singapore kuma tana sanya iyakancewa akan sayen tikiti da talla. Duk da yake tsarin yana da ƙarancin gaske a duniya, yana nuna cewa a cikin yanayin da aka sarrafa sosai, caca na iya haifar da riba mai mahimmanci ba tare da haifar da yaduwar riba ba.

Faransa da kuma FDJ Model

Faransa's Française des Jeux (FDJ) (FLT:1) kamfani ne mai cin kasuwa wanda jihar ke riƙe da hannun jari na 20%. Ana dawo da ribar FDJ zuwa ga jihar ta hanyar rabawa, da haraji daban akan kudaden shiga caca don tallafawa shirye-shiryen zamantakewa. A cikin 2022, FDJ ya ba da gudummawar sama da € 400 miliyan ga kasafin kudin jihar Faransa. Ba kamar tsarin Burtaniya ba, ba a ba da kuɗin fito na caca na Faransa ba. Suna shiga cikin kasafin kuɗi na gaba ɗaya kuma suna tallafawa sabis na jama'a da yawa. Wannan tsarin yana sauƙaƙa gudanarwa amma yana ɓata haɗin kai tsaye tsakanin 'yan wasa da masu amfani. Duk da haka, FDJ ana ɗaukarsa ɗayan mafi ingancin masu gudanar da caca a Turai, tare da ƙarancin kuɗin gudanarwa da babban dawowa ga gwamnati.

Yadda Za a Yi Yin caca a Zamanin Dijital

Tattalin arzikin caca yana ci gaba da sauri saboda fasaha da canza abubuwan da masu amfani ke so. Sayar da tikiti ta kan layi ya faɗaɗa kasuwa, amma kuma yana kawo sabbin ƙalubale na doka da zamantakewa. Canjin dijital yana sake tsara yadda caca ke aiki, yadda ake tallata su, da yadda ake tsara su.

Canjin Dijital

Yawancin manyan caca yanzu suna ba da siyan tikiti ta kan layi ta hanyar yanar gizo da aikace-aikace na hukuma. Wannan canjin yana rage farashin gudanarwa kuma yana kaiwa ga matasa, masu amfani da dijital. Misali, dandamali na kan layi na National Lottery na Burtaniya ya kai sama da 30% na jimlar tallace-tallace. Lotocin dijital kuma yana ba da damar ingantaccen tallan da keɓaɓɓun tayi, haɓaka haɗin kai da kudaden shiga na 'yan wasa. A wasu hukumomi,' yan wasa na iya saita iyakokin kashe kuɗi, duba tarihin siyan su, da karɓar tunatarwa game da caca mai alhaki ta hanyar tashoshin dijital. Duk da haka, samun damar kan layi na iya haɓaka sayen turawa da caca mai matsala, saboda yana kawar da tarkon ziyarar siyarwa ta zahiri.

Haɗa da Sauran Hanyar Yin Caca

Gwamnatoci suna ƙara haɗuwa da caca tare da sauran samfuran caca. A wasu ƙasashen Turai, masu gudanar da caca yanzu suna ba da caca ta wasanni, wasannin nan take na kama-da-wane, har ma da caca ta e-wasu. Wannan yanayin yana ɓoye layin tsakanin caca na gargajiya da caca ta gidan caca, wanda ke iya faɗaɗa tushen samun kuɗi amma kuma yana haɓaka haɗarin jaraba. Yanayin wasan caca na Amurka yana canzawa: yawancin caca na jihohi yanzu suna haɗin gwiwa tare da littattafan caca don ba da wuraren wasan caca da ke da alaƙa da caca. Misali, Lottery na New Jersey ya ƙaddamar da aikace-aikacen caca na wasanni wanda ke ba 'yan wasa damar amfani da caca don sanya caca ta wasanni. Duk da yake waɗannan sababbin abubuwa suna haɓaka kudaden shiga, suna kuma ƙarfafa muhawara game da rawar zamantakewar caca ta jihar.

Blockchain da Bayyanawa

Fasahar Blockchain tana alƙawarin magance damuwar gaskiya ta hanyar yin rikodin duk ma'amaloli na caca a cikin babban littafin jama'a. 'Yan caca na gwaji, kamar Lottery na Bitcoin, sun gwada wannan samfurin. Duk da yake har yanzu suna da kyau, caca ta tushen blockchain na iya ba da tabbacin tabbaci cewa ana rarraba kuɗi kamar yadda aka yi alkawarin. A ka'idar, kwangiloli masu wayo na iya sarrafa biyan kuɗi da kuma tabbatar da cewa kuɗin da aka keɓe sun isa ga inda aka nufa ba tare da tsangwama ba. Duk da haka, yaduwar tallafi yana fuskantar matsalolin doka, haɗarin tsaro, da ƙalubalen haɓaka zuwa girman manyan caca na jihar. Matakan gwaji a Estonia da Malta sun nuna alƙawarin, amma babu wata babbar hukuma da ta himmatu ga cikakken tsarin caca na tushen blockchain.

Ƙaruwar Lotteries da Suka Dace a Yanar Gizo

A matsayin martani ga sukar, wasu caca suna karɓar takaddun shaida na "wasa mai alhaki" kuma suna saka hannun jari sosai a cikin kayan aikin hana lalacewa. Ƙungiyar Lotteries ta Turai ta FLT:1 ta haɓaka shirin takaddun shaida wanda ke duba masu aiki akan kare 'yan wasa, halayyar talla, da kuma nuna gaskiya. Lotteries waɗanda suka cika waɗannan ƙa'idodin na iya nuna hatimin amincewa, suna ba da sanarwar ga masu amfani da cewa suna aiki da ɗabi'a. Wannan motsi yana samun karbuwa tsakanin caca ta Arewacin Amurka. Misali, Kamfanin Lottery na Atlantic a Kanada ya himmatu ga kashe kashi 5% na ribar sa akan bincike da magani na matsalar caca. Duk da yake waɗannan ƙoƙarin suna da yabo, masu shakka suna jayayya cewa basu isa ba lokacin da kewar samfurin na asali ya zama mai jaraba.

Ƙarshen

Tattalin arzikin sayar da tikiti na caca ya bayyana hoto mai ban sha'awa. Gwamnatoci suna amfana daga ci gaba, mai yiwuwa na samun kudin shiga wanda ke tallafawa ilimi, kayayyakin more rayuwa, kiwon lafiya, da ayyukan al'umma. Har ila yau, samfurin yana haifar da ayyuka, yana ƙarfafa ayyukan kiri, kuma yana iya jan hankalin yawon buɗe ido. Duk da haka, wannan tsarin yana sanya farashi ga 'yan wasa masu ƙarancin kuɗi, yana ƙara yawan shan caca, kuma yana tayar da tambayoyi game da caca ta ƙasa. Yayin da masana'antar ke ƙaurawa ta kan layi kuma ta haɗu da sauran samfuran caca, daidaiton tsakanin kudaden shiga da alhakin zai zama mafi ƙaranci. Dole ne masu tsara doka na gaba su auna fa'idodin kuɗi da lalacewar zamantakewa, suna tabbatar da cewa kudaden caca da gaske suna bauta wa jama'a maimakon kawai maye gurbin biyan haraji mai adalci. Tsarin caca mafi nasara zai zama waɗanda suka haɗu da ingantaccen samar da kudaden shiga tare da kiyaye kariyar mai kunnawa da ingantaccen tsari, da kuma rarraba kuɗi a cikin tsarin jama'a.